GENERAL ELECTION IS NOV. 4TH--VOTE!!! Legacy in Motion 2008!


The Michigan FrontPAGE


Media Partners

National Multiple Sclerosis Society


 »  Home  »  Main News  »  Poor choices equal poor leadership
Poor choices equal poor leadership
By Sam Logan, PUBLISHER | Published  07/23/2008 | Main News | Rating:
Detroiters are scraping the bottom of the barrel
The makeup of much of the Detroit School Board, City Council, the Mayor’s Office and some of those elected to the State Legislature from the city are proof positive that Detroiters are scraping the bottom of the barrel when it comes to quality elected officials.

This is painfully reinforced by the tendency of voters to repeatedly elect candidates with little integrity or judgment about what constitutes good public service. Clearly, Detroit is in need of a better mix of educated, sophisticated voters to reconfigure and revitalize the social, political and economic environment.

By any measure, the School Board is a disaster. Parents have heightened frustration with its members’ lack of flexibility and responsiveness. Its meetings are contentious – infighting is more the norm than the exception. Angry, estranged parents feel politically weak, unable to defend the interests of their children or see the benefits of the public school system. They flee the city in droves.

A down and dirty confrontation with new Supt. Connie Calloway seems to be gathering steam. My assesment is that the board misjudged the strength of character of the first- year CEO. Because she came from a small school district, the board felt Calloway could be controlled and manipulated. After discovering that she is no pushover, and steadfastly inclined to publicly reveal the board’s horrific foibles and deplorable past practices, she has been rendered persona non-grata.

Even if parents allow the board to successfully chart Calloway’s demise, students will continue to be held hostage in dysfunctional schools and an expensive bureaucratic fiefdom whose basic mission is to perpetuate itself. That’s proven by history. In short, the board is not only its own worst enemy, it is detrimental to quality education.

The Detroit City Council is another train wreck. Political corruption and the misuse of official power and government resources for private enrichment is not just a casual phenomenon for this legislative body. Allegations of bribery, patronage, nepotism, and the use of public office for personal gain are common.

Complacent and insulated, many on the council spend too much time focusing on issues of personal interest, getting reelected and taking care of their friends. The power of incumbency gives them an unfair advantage to amass large campaign war chests capable of warding off potential challengers and continuing these ethical lapses. Barring some apocalyptic event, or death, the worst of these politicians are immune to defeat. More members of the council die in office than lose a reelection bid.

This political entrenchment breeds arrogance, stifles new ideas and spawns officeholders accountable to no one but themselves. Seniority generates high-pitched, empty rhetoric, but is no guarantee of effectiveness. Neglected and unrepresented neighborhoods are unable to assign responsibility for their mounting problems and declining services or obtain solutions to them.

Then there is Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick. Despite some of his accomplishments in the city, the current issues facing his administration have stifled Detroit on a local, regional and national level. And it has left serious doubts among many about Kilpatrick’s effectiveness to continue to run the city.

Powerless Detroiters find it easy to be cynical and regard politics as the arena where self-interest prevails. Although voters have at their disposal the most effective weapon against incompatible elected officials — the inherent power of the vote to terminate the careers of these political bloodsuckers — they manage to survive. Frustrations are not transformed into recall petition signatures or votes for change.

Outrage and dissatisfaction is at a fever pitch every day but election day. Less than half of registered Detroiters typically turn out in city elections. But that is not unusual in cities where most of the talent and wealth now reside in the suburbs.

The remaining occupants keep voting in notoriously imperial, corrupt government officials because they don’t see that the costs of the malfeasance and sleaze are destructive. They don’t understand that when discretionary favors are dispensed and controlled through networks established by shady operators in exchange for votes, it raises the cost of doing business.

Uncertainty erodes business confidence and the small businessman or businesswoman becomes less viable – denied access to the government. Those businesses with political connections become shielded from competition as the economic marketplace is subverted and efficiency hampered by illicit payoffs. A distorted political hierarchy fails to generate great wealth and income or deliver essential services. Abandoned retail stores, boarded-up restaurants and houses and scarce jobs become part of the equation at the expense of residents.

The middle class, capable of managing, planning and advising, disappears. When they move, they take the skills, education and connections that make successful communities work. They leave a pool of powerless poor people who are at a disadvantage in having their basic needs met. Since only a minority of Detroiters still value good government, they have no means to address or reverse the city’s fortunes. That requires a broader base of young, educated new residents, the likes of which abandoned the city years ago.

I can already hear the chorus of some Detroiters bemoaning the prospect of a major influx of White residents into the city who might again seize political control. It will be convenient for them to make a villain out of any attempt to gentrify the political process. Some critics, of course, fear a future in which their exclusive advocacy for the chronic poor is rendered irrelevant by what might become a rising tide of more educated, committed residents contributing to uplifting economic growth.

But think for a moment: Why would any intelligent outside force want to take over a city with a racially divided people, decaying infrastructure, dwindling services, a disappearing tax base, a shrinking population and a budget immersed in permanent red ink?

There is no debate that much of the self-sustaining, enterprising spirit that launched Detroit’s growth 50 years ago is gone. Most suburbanites think of Detroit as a financial and moral wasteland rife with accelerating crime, genocidal violence and disturbing family malfunction.

Yet the only way this city will survive is if there is a re-population with a new class of virtuous, ethical people. Only when we transition to a more politically appropriate realignment and expand our demographic bases of power can we dream of a new status quo. Without a major dose of gentrification, we simply do not have much of a future.

The governance structure we have chosen is in large part a reflection of who we are. For too long, we have empowered the wrong people to make decisions that affect our lives and our futures to the point there are not many reasons for new entrants to want to make Detroit their home. This must change.

Like it or not, the people we have placed in office are no more and no less than we deserve. With a new vision and the addition of new, reform-minded residents, we can do better.
Comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by Pam, orginally from Detroit)
    Rating
    What in the world is going on in my hometown?!? I read the Free Press almost daily, and of course I read the Michigan Chronicle. Between the drama with the school system, and the debacle that is "leadership" in City Hall, I am in tears. I brag all of the time that Detroit is my hometown here in NC, and the comments that I get in return are most embarrassing, due to poor leadership and stewardship. Where are our ministers to encourage Kwame Kilpatrick to give up the ghost? Where are the leaders who are demanding excellence and accountability of our schools? I saw photos of schools closed down in Detroit with hundreds of computers and books litering empty classrooms. Why aren't these expensive items paid by taxpayers not being used by the children? I just don't understand, how this is my hometown. This is NOT the Detroit I grew up in.
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by kaleema)
    Rating
    I have read the article and it was quite disappointing. I am on of those poor, uneducated (??) Detroiters who are concerned about the revitalization of the city and the school system. However, I have historical memory and have to ask everyone, including myself what have you done within your class status, economic status and status within the power structure done to help Detroit? Why are the schools so poorly managed, the educated, middle and upper classes run the school system. What is the reason "poor" children can't be educated, formerly slave children right out of slavery could be educated - what is the difference between those educators, students and parents and today's educators, students and parents? What is the difference between Frederick Douglas newspaper and the Michigan Chronicle and the Michigan Front Page? Or for that matter between any black owned newspaper today and the ones owned by Ida B. Wells Barnett? What about Dr. Bethune and any advocate for the education of "poor" black children today? In those most racist times Dr. Bethune made things happen for children and she did not take large numbers of children and parents with her, though she would and could have, today's leaders are not even able to stop the negative effects of No Child Left Behind.

    Considering that there are so many issues and problems in the black community, in Detroit we need to be a critically thinking community rather than one that merely reacts to the criticism directed towards it.

    The truth is what is happening now, in my humble opinion resembles the "willie lynch" syndrome so much circulated in the community. It also resembles a community wide knee jerk reactionism to our current conditions.

    And I could add, if Detroit is so bad and we are so uneducated, how do you explain George Bush's two terms as president, the American war on the Iraqi people, and the continuous and expanding system of inequality based upon race in this country?

    Thank you
    Kaleema

     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Roz)
    Rating
    I was a lifelong Detroit residence until four years ago, having relocated to Lansing, MI. I wholeheartly agree that Detroiters have allowed these transgressions with the school system and the local political situation to exist for much too long. I attended Detroit public schools, having gradutated 37 years ago. The education I received at that time was equivalent to a community college eductation today. I had no faith in the school systenm 27 years ago, when my daugther entered kindergarten. She attended private and Catholic schools then. She was excepted at Renaissance High in the 9th grade, where she subsequently graduated Although this school was and still is considered an accelerated academic school, before beginning her freshman year there, DPS had a monthlong strike. There were situations where students at Renaissance did not have sufficient books and supplies. Despite these issues that were not accustomed to, she excelled at Renaissance and has recently attained her masters degree in the sciene field. So, until the residents of Detroit have uprising over their treatment by their elected officials, Detroit will continue to die.
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by Valerie)
    Rating
    I don't understand what is going on in Detroit. It appears that there is a lot of poor decision making going on. Being a former Detroiter myself, I can say that all the schools have been affected for a long time. Children have been made to suffer throughout all of our deficiencies, the strikes the first things to go are the extra-curricular programs. Where are the parents? Who is praying? There used to be a saying when you leave Detroit turn out the lights. Are we there again? Kwame is the youngest mayor in history in Detroit. Not is he only making history with his age but with frolicking also. This is a mess I have lived in Detroit since I was 9yrs until I was 41. I see the automotive industry going away which was a prime resource in the economy of Detroit. Do we retrain and regroup so that we can keep up with a struggling economy or do we, just sit ariound and talk about how messed up our city is?
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by Jennifer Wallisch)
    Rating
    As a white resident, and a student majoring in urban planning and development here in Detroit, I can't help but take offense when I read about people being upset about my choice to live here. I was raised three miles up the street, and watched in horror as residents in Detroit allowed their beautiful city to rot and burn to the ground. I am told that no matter what qualifications I bring, the color of my skin will probably disqualify me from holding any public office here. Sound familiar? Racism is an ugly,evil blot on our city's social fabric, and the constant baiting from people and politicians regarding race only creates a stalemate and prevents us from moving forward. If being black and/or rich is the only qualification needed to run the show around here, than expect us to deal with these problems for a very long time. And so what if more white folks move to Detroit? The houses are still vacant from when they left the first time, and chances are they will be younger,much more open minded and progressive than their parents were. I am a human being willing to give everything I've got to help create a better Detroit and have already spent most of my life pouring blood, sweat, and tears into this place. I love Detroit, and how I shouldn't count, I don't understand.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by MichiganFan87)
    Rating
    I just did some quick research of Congresswoman Kilpatrick's legislative record - via her official congressional web site and here's what I found:

    105 Congress (1997-98): 3 bills introduced and none were approved
    106 Congress (1999-00): 5 bills introduced and none were approved; 1 amendment offered and not approved.
    107 Congress (2001-02): 3 bills introduced and none were approved
    108 Congress (2003-04): 7 bills introduced and none were approved; 1 amendment offered and not approved.
    109 Congress (2005-06): 5 bills introduced and only 1 was approved; 2 amendments were offered and only 1 was approved.
    110 Congress (2007-08) 6 bills introduced and none approved; 2 amendments offered and not approved.

    Since Congresswoman Kilpatrick was first elected in 1996, she's only introduced 29 bills and only 1 - JUST 1 bill was approved. That's a success rate of only 3.4%. It took ten years for her to get something approved by the House of Representatives. Isn't anyone checking her record?

    Why is she wasting our time and getting nothing done? We need to make some serious changes and this would be a start. Let's elect someone to Congress that can improve the lives of Detroiters and those of the State of Michigan.



     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by Joe Joseph)
    Rating
    I am going to make some people angry by what I say here, but the Schools, city infrastructure, city council and our beloved Mayor are not the disease, just symptoms of it. What destroyed so much of Detroit as we all know were the tragic riots of 1967.

    After the riots the last vestages of the white dominated political system were in the death throes of Jerry Canvinaugh and Roman Gribbs. After Mayor Gribbs who is still alive by the way, Detroit made a decision; decisions have consequences and the wrong decision was made. Mayor Coleman Young did nothing to reassure the white business establishment or the white and upwardly mobile black folks to stay in the City. Mayor Young created a political machine that exists to this day and Mayor Kwame is the result. Detroit is rulled by a thug.

    Men like Dave Bing or Dennis Archer could do a LOT to restore confidence in the business community to do projects in Detroit.

    We also have to consider the benefit that Poor Choices have created for a minority of folks in our once proud city. Corruption is rampant but may be preferable to dealing with inflexible bureaucrats in some cities. This fact argues well for corruption. As a businessman I would rather "contribute" than be beaten over the heads with paper clubs.

    Look at the nations biggest retailer, Walmart; did you folks realize that Detroit is the ONLY city with over a population of 500,000 that does NOT have a Walmart? What about supermarkets? Do you believe the majority of independent grocers in this city would welcome the chains back? No, the grocers have their scams all to themselves now and I trust Farmer Jack is now only an unpleasant memory.

    The problem however is how we convince the business community, black and white to give Detroit another chance.

    A tough sell indeed; Mr. Bing could pull it off but people get the leaders the deserve and unfortunately most Detroiters I fear like the present system.
     
Submit Comment



Article Options

Digital Edition

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

Subscribe by Credit Card Online
 
Subscribe